The Sheboygan Athletic Club initiated its Hall of Fame in 1993 to honor those players and club members deserving of recognition for extraordinary ability or service to the organization.
Players become eligible for the Hall of Fame five years after they have retired. The Hall of Fame Committee discusses eligible players. When a player is proposed for nomination to the Hall of Fame, he must receive a favorable vote by two-thirds of the committee. If that occurs the nomination is forwarded to the Sheboygan Athletic Club Board of Directors which must approve the nomination unanimously.